Changing South Dakota’s social studies standards has become an increasingly contentious quest, which is why Gov. Kristi Noem made a wise choice Monday to delay making those changes for up to a year to field more public input on the topic.

Of course, this has become a minefield of the governor’s own making.

Several months ago, Noem called for changing the standards to reflect “our nation’s true and honest history,” as she put it in a press release issued Monday.

This echoes former President Donald Trump’s call last year for the formation of a so-called 1776 Commission to devise standards for a curriculum that would provide “patriotic education” for students. This would be done, it was suggested, by emphasizing the “core principles of the American founding and how these principles may be understood to further enjoyment of ‘the blessings of liberty.’”

This would, among other things, likely downplay the role of racism and sanitize other blemishes in the nation’s history. It would also target Critical Race Theory (CRT), which South Dakota educators note is geared more for higher education and isn’t used in the state’s curriculum plans.

In South Dakota, these changes also apparently mean de-emphasizing the role of Native American culture in our history.

Over the summer, a state-approved group worked in Pierre to draft the new social studies guidelines Noem called for, but the resulting proposal was then altered by the Department of Education, removing some references to Native Americans.

This drew sharp criticism, with the South Dakota Education Equity Coalition holding a rally in Pierre last week and calling for Noem’s resignation.

According to the Argus Leader, the feedback received so far to the proposed changes has been largely critical. Also, a public meeting that was scheduled for Aberdeen has been moved to a different venue to accommodate a larger crowd. Whether that meeting happens as planned is not known at this point.

Nevertheless, Noem remains determined to push ahead, based on a Twitter post Monday. She declared: “In every state, radical education activists are scheming in order to impose CRT & Action Civics. I just froze the review of SD’s K-12 social studies standards (because) I have concerns. Restoring honest & true American & South Dakota history in our schools won’t be easy but we must win.”

There is so much in this issue that is relative and politically charged. Obviously, the term “radical education activists” is terribly subjective, purposely vague and divisive, which only deepens the worry that explicitly mentioning CRT as a “radical” target could be blurred in some quarters into a reference to any racial topic that appears to criticize a white- and European-dominated status quo.

There is more to America and to South Dakota than that, and such facets must also be part of the “true and honest history” that politicians say they desire. The fact that our history isn’t perfect, isn’t without flaws and mistakes, and is multicultural with sometimes conflicting missions must not be lost in any definition of who we are, for understanding our complexities ultimately makes us stronger.

So, getting more feedback on this issue is a sensible path forward, although how much of it will be heeded in the long run remains to be seen. Still, South Dakotans should take advantage of this opportunity to speak up when the situation presents itself.

kmh

(10) comments

Red Cloud

How amusing to watch the sanctimonious bleeding hearts and the fearful, guilty-denying racists among you immigrants arguing with each other over how to describe your theft of this land from its previous inhabitants.

Friedrich Farmer

Has anyone else noticed how long it’s taking for our comments to post?

It sure takes away from the dialogue flow that we used to enjoy.

ClownsRus

Tell me about it.

And forget about seeing anything you post in the afternoon.

Jolly Roger

Look! The squeaky wheel gets the grease. Maybe the rest of us need to complain as well.

suess52

Thank you.

suess52

Perhaps the Governor should concern herself with the health and well being of her citizens. South Dakota is number 12 of the 50 states in per capita death rates from COVID.

Abe

ahem... you misspelled Remdisivir

SoDakD

⁉️

Mr. T

I’ve noticed this problem with my postings too. My comments have sometimes been lost completely.

I just reposted a response to Mr. Wick that was a straight-forward and respectful dialogue but somehow got misplaced in the feed following “Was Riverboat Days A Super-Spreader?”

Seems to me this isn’t censorship. It just might be incompetence.

That’s often the most likely explanation.

Who needs conspiracies?

Red Cloud

The more I think about it, the clearer it becomes why Governor Noem is kicking this can down the road.

South Dakota’s version of the conflict over Critical Race Theory is upsetting you immigrants isn’t it?

Sure is… Look at all the above irrelevant comments.

In all its versions, CRT is the examination of how one race dominates in America. Something that’s been clear since the Founding. Something you pale ones find uncomfortable to acknowledge.

It’s been this way almost since the moment Columbus “discovered” America. This has always been obvious to some of us.

But what’s new is that Euro-Americans will soon be a minority. And CRT reminds you folks that before long you’ll be living in a USA where Black, Brown, Yellow and Red Americans will be the majority. And you're afraid of what’s coming. Aren’t you?

Together with the younger Euro-Americans who care more about the elusive “American Dream” than their race loyalty, this new version of America is changing your traditional white people’s politics.

This might take several generations. But the demographics make it seem certain. Old white people have gathered together in the GOP to make a last stand, but the numbers are against them.

South Dakota and the rest of America is going through an identity crisis. You can already see the beginnings in South Dakota’s few cities.

And just a few minutes watching national TV will show you much of the rest of the country is NOT mostly European stock like our fair state.

All around you is the most racially diverse generation in U.S. history: About 45% of millennials and nearly 50% of Gen Zers are people of color, compared with only 30% of you white baby boomers.

Your kids are more comfortable in this new America than you are. Yet I know what you're going through. You see your way of life threatened.

If I were more objective, I might even have sympathy.

But at least you’ll be able to keep your property.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.