Yankton residents got a glimpse of two very distinct views regarding mask mandates Monday.

In chronological order, it played out this way:

• At 5 p.m., the Yankton School Board convened in a short special session to unanimously endorse a letter urging the City Commission to enact a mask mandate to thwart the spread of COVID-19. The board pointed not only to recommendations from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) regarding masks, but also to its own experiences. The Yankton School District (YSD) has operated with a mask mandate since the school year started in August, and it has mostly been successful;

• An hour later, the Yankton City Commission met in a work session prior to its regular meeting in order to discuss mask options. A majority of the commissioners were reticent to impose a mandate, especially one with penalties. In the regular meeting, the board voted to end discussions on masking options and instead considered pursuing a $38,000 effort to educate the public on the importance of mask wearing.

Thus, the city decided it may want to pursue mask education, while the educators, who have three months of experience with mask mandates, called on the city to take that step, too.

Meanwhile, the toll of the coronavirus on Yankton County climbs. There were 46 new infections reported Tuesday, giving the county 625 new cases this month, an increase of 67%.

Franky, the City Commission’s decision would be viewed as practical if it was still last March or April, when the COVID-19 pandemic really began to impact our lives. But now, with cases climbing dramatically across the state and especially in Yankton County, the commission wants to educate people on something they already know. And make no mistake, those who oppose a temporary mask mandate aren’t unaware of what the CDC is saying or of what the daily Department of Health updates (which are mostly lagging indicators of the problem at hand) are describing. They know the score. Instead, they view the mandate as an infringement on their rights — which, in this case, would be their right to potentially infect others.

This takes us back to the school board’s discussion. YSD’s mask policy has worked within its walls, but it’s also an island in a county with considerable community spread.

“We have found, within the school district, that the masks have been very beneficial and, to date, we have found that almost all infections are coming from outside in,” School Board President Sarah Carda said.

According to the letter the board approved, “Over 99% of the COVID-19 cases among students and staff in our school tracing are coming from community spread. We believe this could be significantly mitigated by implementing a community mask requirement.”

But the City Commission also looked at the enforceability issues with a mandate, as well as the pushback from opponents. Some of that was fielded Monday night via YouTube, including one person who accused the commissioners of being communists for even considering such a mandate.  

So, the commissioners settled on a “middle course,” which is to continue what the state and city have done since the pandemic began: to educate and encourage. To date, that hasn’t worked well, as more than 800 South Dakotans who have passed away from COVID-related issued might attest.

But, since we’re here again, we must pray for the best with this renewed educational push and plead with people to be good students. Do it for others — your family, your friends — if not for yourself. Exercise your freedom to protect those you love. For goodness sake, mask up.

kmh

(10) comments

Steve Jacobsen

This is Chris Jacobsen responding.

I am discouraged by the Council’s decision, but not surprised. Why? The Council is charged to represent the citizens of the city. They did.

The majority of people in Yankton, though it is a shrinking majority, don’t believe masking to be necessary.

I point to 2 divergent pieces of evidence in today’s paper: page 14 and the online opinion poll.

Yankton resident

Spot on Kelly, great op ed. By the way on line polls are not scientific, just a reminder for those who may think so.l

Steve Jacobsen

I don’t think so either.....just an interesting ‘look’!

Cj

YanktonCitizen2

I'm disappointed that the city commission could not come to a different decision. I'm not sure how much more education we need. We drive on the correct side of the road, don't smoke in public buildings because it's the law, and don't see those things as an infringement of our rights. I don't know why mask wearing needs to be so different. Since we are being told to shop local, I hope more small business owners and their employees will start wearing masks ... or get creative and offer online shopping and shipping of gifts. Otherwise, I think many will still turn to Amazon. It's a lot easier and safer.

MyThoughts

[thumbup]

Yankton resident

DLJohnson: It is clear you have very little understanding of SDCL or ordinances with a sunset clause. By ordinance you can attach a petty offense to it, if you chose not to do that there are civil remedies as well. You would be quite surprised at the number of state statues that have no criminal penalty, but are yet enforceable and enforced. Get a grip on yourself before you respond to something you know nothing about.

mleibfarth

In Omaha there is a mask mandate for months. Not difficult to comply. All businesses should absolutely mandate employees wear masks. Many will not enter your business if no masks. Community spread is very much affecting many people and businesses for when an employee becomes ill they are out of work. Businesses are operating very short staffed. The upper Midwest hospitals that are filled, even near full are short staff and the healthcare workers are exhausted. Those close to retirement retired. They reach out to hire temporary staff and there are none available. All the information is out. You would have to live in a cave to not know exactly what to do. CDC, NEWSPARERS, TV NEWS. And as a taxpayer in Yankton you seriously want them to spend 38,000? I just learned another Yankton resident passed away from Covid. How sad.

MyThoughts

mieibfarth [thumbup]

suess52

This is a health crisis. Emergency measures must be put into place. We must do everything we can to protect our citizens. Wearing a face mask and social distancing is a small sacrifice to save lives.

MyThoughts

[thumbup] On this, I agree with you

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.