The words that flowed from Donald Trump this past weekend — words on social media that told four congressional representatives who are women of color that they should “go back to their own countries” for their criticism of conditions at U.S. border detention centers — were nothing new.

That ugly sentiment is almost as old as this nation itself. (NPR reported that, according to one history professor, it hails back to 1798 when the U.S. passed the Alien and Sedition Acts, which were designed to clamp down on immigrants and potentially boot them from the country for criticizing the government.)

The words were as familiar and as painful as any other racial taunt that has been uttered throughout our history.

We’ve heard this before, to be sure — but not from the president of the United States. Not from a person who is supposed to represent what this nation stands for and what America — a sprawling mosaic of immigrants — is all about.

And yet, this ugliness from this source doesn’t seem surprising. Even to supporters of the president, that fact is a shame and a disgrace, or at least it should be.

The president has drawn a lot of heat for his comments, but so what? That happens on a weekly basis. We seem to be suffering from outrage fatigue.

Some are defending him, but their justifications may say more about them than they do about the president.

Others say nothing at all. The members of South Dakota’s own congressional delegation, all of whom are Republicans like the president, haven’t said too much about Trump’s divisive, destructive, racially charged comment. (To be fair, Rep. Dusty Johnson reportedly told a Sioux Falls television station Monday that he thought the president’s tweet was “inappropriate” and the “wrong way to communicate,” which feels like delicate phrasing.) Until they fill that void, let’s insert these words by the late Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. as a place holder: “In the end, we will remember not the words of our enemies, but the silence of our friends.”

On Monday, President Trump doubled down on his weekend assault, telling the four female representatives he attacked, “If you hate our country, if you’re not happy here, you can leave.”

This, too, is a familiar rant from America’s history, an echo of the cry “America: Love it or leave it” that was often expressed during the turbulent days of the late 1960s and early 1970s. It meant you either stood by America’s policies (in that case, regarding the Vietnam War, for instance) or get the hell out. No middle ground was allowed.

The phrase itself is grounded in our history, inspired by the declaration, “My country, right or wrong.” This phrase, which many perceive as a profession of devout patriotism and unquestioning loyalty, also has an intriguing past.

It’s believed to have originally been uttered as an after-dinner toast by Stephen Decatur, a U.S. naval officer, just after the War of 1812. He said: “Our Country! In her intercourse with foreign nations, may she always be in the right; but right or wrong, our country!”

In 1872, Carl Shurz, a German who migrated to America in the 1840s and then became a prominent member of the newly formed Republican Party, amended the toast to better fit his adopted, post-Civil War homeland: “My country, right or wrong; if right, to be kept right; and if wrong, to be set right.” There’s nothing in those words about leaving America if you “feel otherwise;” there’s nothing implying that people should go back where they came from. Instead, it’s a plea to support and embrace America by making it better, even when it may require a change of direction, because that’s what makes this nation stronger.

That’s what love of country is really all about: If you care, make it right.

Trump’s words ventured into some ugly territory, but they really didn’t seem out of character, and that may be the biggest disappointment of all. But such sentiments must face a reckoning, for though they may be sown into the darkest corners of America’s soul, they cannot ultimately stand for this country’s ideas and ideals.

Americans are better than that. We have to be.


(4) comments


"Trump’s words ventured into some ugly territory..." Trump's word weren't just ugly. They are un-American. Denigrating others based on their national origin is clearly part of his 2020 re-election strategy. Trump's calculation is that his overwhelming white base will agree with and be energized by his racist's statement.


Excellent points. I find it very sad that his supporters are ok with him telling them to go back where they came from. If we all followed his advice then only Native Americans would be left! I wonder if he ever tells his wife that?

RIP Common Sense

Well said, Kelly. The chilling effect is the normalization of such rhetoric. "If the President can say it, I can say it." What really bothers me is that some Americans strut around as if they have the birthright, monopoly on what it means to be a "real" or "true" American. Such a philosophy is absolutely nauseating. If no one ever had the fortitude to speak out, where would this country be? My response to the Trumpians who believe that anyone who does not subscribe to their beliefs should leave, I would simply posit this: If you don't believe in democracy (as messy as it can be), then perhaps it is you who should be buying that ticket to elsewhere.


His followers, picking up he tone, as they chanted at his rally. Shades of Hitler rallies.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.